Episode 20 Court Martial/ The Homecoming & The Circle & The Siege Eric digs the smooth moves by McCoy and kirks Galantry in Court Martial. Bob Digs the grand sweep and Die Hard Station Action of the Three Part DS9 opener. Scores; Court Martail Bob 7, Eric 8 / The Homecoming 1-3 Bob and Eric 8
Episode 19 Tomorrow is Yesterday / In the Hands of the Prophets. Eric loves the humor and time travel shenanigans on TOS and Bob enjoys some political assassination in the DS9 Season 1 finale. Final Scores: Tomorrow is Yesterday: Bob 9.5 / Eric 9. In the Hands of the Prophets: Bob and Eric 8
Episode 18 Arena / Duet. Bob and Eric are joined again by Thom Parham to discuss two classics. Bob and Thom wax lyrical about Gorns and Vasquez Rocks while Eric finds 60's fight scenes laughable. Thom & Eric singe the praises of Duet but Bob remains a little cold. Arena Scores Thom & Bob 9, Eric 8.5 / Duet Scores Thom 9.5, Eric 9, Bob 8.5
Episode 17 The Squire of Gothos / Dramatis Personae. Thom Parham joins Eric and I to discuss the dandyness of Trelane and the out-of-character acting of the main Cast on DS9. The Squire of Gothos Scores Bob: 8.5 Eric & Thom: 9 / Dramatis Personae Bob 5 / Thom 5.5 / Eric 8.5.
Episode 16 The Galileo Seven / The Forsaken. Eric relishes seeing Spock's first command and Bob sees a new side to Odo and Bashir. The Galileo Seven Scores Bob 9 / Eric 10 / The Forsaken Scores Bob 6.5 / Eric 7.5
Episode 15 Shore Leave / If Wishes Were Horses. The wonderful world of fantasy and imagination. Eric digs the surreal pleasure planet and Yeoman Barrows in Shore Leave and Bob ponders the true nature of 'imagination' aliens and Rumplestilskin in If Wishes Were Horses. Shore Leave Collective score 8.5 / If Wishes Were Horses Bob 6.5 / Eric 7.75
Episode 14 Balance of Terror / Progress. Eric's love of the Romulans and Mark Lenard's performance delivers a top notch TOS Episode. Bob's finds possibly the most boring episode of DS9. Balance of Terror Collective Score: 9 Progress Scores: Bob 3 / Eric 4
Episode 13 The Conscience of the King / The Storyteller. Eric loves diving into the Shakespeare murder and revenge on TOS. Bob enjoys O'Brien's 'storytelling' antics but is bored with the B love story with Nog. Scores - The Conscience of the King: Bob 7 / Eric 10, The Storyteller: Bob 6 / Eric 8
Episode 12 The Menagarie Pts 1 & 2 / Battle Lines. Eric welcomes the return of Pilot Spock, Mutiny Spock and Starfleet Death Penalties. Bob is overwhelmed by Jonathan banks and technobabble and the lack of impact of a non-regular character. Scores The Menagarie 1 & 2: Bob 9 / Eric 8, Battle Lines Bob 6 / Eric 7
Episode 11 The Corbomite Maneuver / Vortex. Eric dives into Tranya enriched goodness of this week's TOS (one of Bob's favs) and Bob finds out more about Odo and wonders why there's no Vortex in "Vortex" Scores: The Corbomite Maneuver Bob 9.5 / Eric 8.5 Vortex: Bob 7 / Eric 6.5
Episode 10 Dagger of the Mind / The Nagus. Eric is intrigued at lunatics and mental wards of the 23rd century. Bob Rolls his eyes at the first of the "Ferengi" DS9 episodes. Dagger of the Mind Scores: Bob 7.5 / Eric 8.5 and The Nagus Scores: Bob 4 / 6.75
Episode 9 Miri / Move Along Home. Eric is creeped out by Kirk leading on an "underage" girl and Bob finds the high concept "Deadly Maze" outing for DS9 different and appealing. Miri Collective Score: 7 and Move Along Home Collective Score: 8
Episode 8 What Are Little Girls Made Of? / The Passenger. Ericdigs on Android Kirk and Christine Chapel's reunion. Bob is baffledby Bashir's possessed "acting". Bob also names Sherry Jackson asone of the ultimate Star Trek Babe Trifecta. What Are LittleGirls Made Of? Scores: Bob 8 / Eric 9 and The Passenger Scores: Bob6 / Eric 6.5
Episode 7 Mudd's Women / Dax. Eric is charmed by HarryMudd and one of the women's green dresses and Bob is underwhelmedby Dax's bland personality. Mudd's Women Split Score: Bob 8/ Eric 8.5 and Dax Split Scores: Bob 5 / Eric 6.25
Episode 6 The Enemy Within / Q-Less. Eric is uneasy with the closing line but remains impressed with the Evil Kirk or rather Shatner's acting. Bob is happy to see Q show up on the Station but wonders what's up with Vash. The Enemy Within Collective Score 9 / Q-Less Split Scores: Bob 7 / Eric 7.5
Episode 5 The Naked Time / Captive Pursuit. Eric begins to wonder how Ensign Joe graduated Starfleet Academy but digs on the drunk crew. Bob wonders about 24th Century money and replicators but appreciates O'Brien's new Gamma Quadrant buddy. The Naked Time Split Scores Bob 8 / Eric 8.5 and Captive Pursuit Split Scores: Bob 7 / Eric 8
Episode 4 Where No Man Has Gone Before / Babel. Eric compares TOS pilots and enjoys the return of 'Pilot" Spock. Bob kinda digs on the language impaired outing for DS9. Where No Man Has Gone Before scores: Bob 7 / Eric 8.5 Babel Scores: 7.5
Episode 3 Reviews TOS: Charlie X and DS9: Past Prologue. Eric Declares "The Problem of Kira's Men" begins here. However, Eric continues to love The Original Series, Bob feels DS9 just treads along. Charlie X Score: 8.5 Past Prologue Score: 5.5
We pick up discussing TOS: The Man Trap and DS9: A Man Alone. Eric continues to be impressed, Bob remains underwhelmed. Final Scores The Man Trap: 9, A Man Alone: 5
We kick off our first double length episode discussing the Pilots for both TOS and DS9. Eric Gives the Cage a thumbs up and Bob finds a mixed bag for Emissary. The Cage Score: 9, Emissary Score: 7